Functional Outcome of Intramedullary Nailing vs Plating in Tibial Shaft Fracture: Functional Outcome of Intramedullary Nailing vs Plating in Tibial Shaft Fracture

Aamir Zareen; Muhammad Salar Khan; Hassan Khan; Muhammad Khan; Sajawal Mukhtiar

doi:10.54393/pjhs.v7i9.4281

Authors

Aamir Zareen Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan
Muhammad Salar Khan Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan
Hassan Khan Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan
Muhammad Khan Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan
Sajawal Mukhtiar Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54393/pjhs.v7i9.4281

Keywords:

Tibial Shaft Fracture, Intramedullary Nailing, Plate Fixation, Functional Outcome, Johner-Wruhs Criteria

Abstract

Fractures of the tibial shaft are typical long-bone injuries that are accompanied by a high rate of morbidity. Surgical procedures such as intramedullary nailing and plate fixation are common, although there is controversy over the most effective approach owing to variations in healing rates and complication rates. Objective: To compare the functional outcomes of intramedullary nailing and plate fixation in patients with tibial shaft fractures. Methods: This was a prospective comparative study conducted in the Department of Orthopedics, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, from March 2023 to August 2024. 110 patients aged between 18 and 60 years were enrolled. Both closed fractures and Gustilo-Anderson type I and II open fractures were considered eligible. Pathological fracture, polytrauma with intensive care, neurovascular injury, Gustilo type III open fracture, or previous surgery of the affected limb in patients were excluded. Results: A total of 110 patients were included. Mean time to union was significantly shorter in the intramedullary nailing group than in the plating group (16.2 ± 3.8 vs. 19.1 ± 4.5 weeks; p=0.001). Overall, union was achieved in 92.7% of patients. Excellent to good functional outcomes were higher in the intramedullary nailing group compared with the plating group (83.6% vs. 72.7%), although the difference was not statistically significant (p=0.180). Conclusions: Intramedullary nailing offers earlier fracture union and faster recovery, while both techniques provide comparable functional outcomes. The choice of fixation should be individualized based on patient and fracture characteristics.

References

Li X, Chen K, Xue H, Cheng J, Yu X. Efficacy Comparison Between Intramedullary Nail Fixation and Plate Fixation in Distal Tibia Fractures: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Journal of Orthopedic Surgery and Research. 2024 Jul; 19(1) :403. doi: 10.1186/s13018-024-04900-y. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13018-024-04900-y

Xu H, Chen P, Zhang Y, Huang H, Xie X, Ren Z. Intramedullary Nailing Versus Minimally Invasive Plate Osteosynthesis for Proximal Tibial Fracture: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research. 2025 Jul; 20(1): 663. doi: 10.1186/s13018-025-06094-3. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13018-025-06094-3

Dragonas CG, Fontalis A, Iliadis A, Vris A, Mavrogenis A. Intramedullary Nailing Versus Plate Fixation for the Treatment of Proximal Tibia Extra-Articular Fractures: A Meta-Analysis. European Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Traumatology. 2025 Sep; 35(1): 410. doi: 10.1007/s00590-025-04536-6. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-025-04536-6

Garabano G, Pereira S, Perez Alamino L, Ernst G, Pesciallo CA, Bidolegui F. The Relevance of the Number of Distal Locking Planes and Nail to Canal Ratio in Bone Healing After Intramedullary Nailing in Tibial Shaft Fractures. European Journal of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology. 2023 Jul; 33(5): 2111-9. doi: 10.1007/s00590-022-03401-0. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-022-03401-0

Dunbar RP, Egol KA, Jones CB, Ostrum RF, Humphrey CA, Ricci WM et al. Locked Plating Versus Nailing for Proximal Tibia Fractures: A Multicenter Randomized Controlled Trial. Journal of Orthopedic Trauma. 2023 Apr; 37(4): 155-60. doi: 10.1097/BOT.0000000000002537. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/BOT.0000000000002537

Cheng L, Li YH, Chu Y, Yang G, Zhu D, Tan L. Intramedullary Nailing Via Suprapatellar Approach Versus Locked Plating of Proximal Extra-Articular Tibial Fractures: A Randomized Control Trial. International orthopedics. 2021 Jun; 45(6): 1599-608. doi: 10.1007/s00264-020-04821-5. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00264-020-04821-5

Radaideh A, Alrawashdeh MA, Al Khateeb AH, Obeidat O, Tabar MA, Essa SM et al. Outcomes of Treating Tibial Shaft Fractures Using Intramedullary Nailing Versus Minimally Invasive Percutaneous Plate Osteosynthesis. Medical Archives. 2022 Feb; 76(1): 55. doi: 10.5455/medarh.2022.76.55-61.

O’Neill CN, Hooper N, Wait J, Satalich J, Cinats D, Toney C et al. No Difference in Short‐Term Complications Following Treatment of Closed Tibial Shaft Fractures with Intramedullary Nailing Versus Plate Fixation. Advances in Orthopedics. 2023 Oct; 1: 1627225. doi: 10.1155/2023/1627225. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2023/1627225

Upfill-Brown A, Hwang R, Clarkson S, Brodke D, Devana S, Mayer E et al. Rates and Timing of Short-Term Complications Following Operative Treatment of Tibial Shaft Fractures. Orthopedic Trauma Association International. 2021 Dec; 4(4): e158. doi: 10.1097/OI9.0000000000000158. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/OI9.0000000000000158

Balbachevsky D, Gomes PS, Credídio MV, Cruz BA, Fernandes HJ, Dos Reis FB et al. Intramedullary Nail Versus Bridge Plate in Open Tibial Fractures: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Injury. 2021 Jul; 52: 77-83. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2021.06.015. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2021.06.015

Radaideh A, Alrawashdeh MA, Al Khateeb AH, Obeidat O, Tabar MA, Essa SM et al. Outcomes of Treating Tibial Shaft Fractures Using Intramedullary Nailing Versus Minimally Invasive Percutaneous Plate Osteosynthesis. Medical Archives. 2022 Feb; 76(1): 55. doi: 10.5455/medarh.2022.76.55-61. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5455/medarh.2022.76.55-61

Turley L, Barry I, Sheehan E. Frequency of Complications in Intramedullary Nailing of Open Tibial Shaft Fractures: A Systematic Review. Effort Open Reviews. 2023 Feb; 8(2): 90-9. doi: 10.1530/EOR-22-0076. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1530/EOR-22-0076

Morello V and Gamulin A. Clinical and Radiological Risk Factors Associated with the Occurrence of Acute Compartment Syndrome in Tibial Fractures: A Systematic Review of the Literature. EFORT Open Reviews. 2023 Dec; 8(12): 926-35. doi: 10.1530/EOR-23-0067. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1530/EOR-23-0067

Kalhor M, Elahifar O, Eslami A, Gharehdaghi J. Anatomy and Pattern of Tibial Periosteal Circulation: Implications for Tibial Plating: A Cadaveric Study. Bone and Joint Research. 2025 Se3; 14(9): 769. doi: 10.1302/2046-3758.149.BJR-2024-0547.R2. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1302/2046-3758.149.BJR-2024-0547.R2

Monahan KT, Zavras AG, Angelides GW, Altman GT, Altman DT, Westrick ER. Extra-Articular Proximal Tibia Fracture Fixation with Locked Plating Versus Intramedullary Nailing: A Meta-Analysis. Injury. 2024; 55(10): 111718. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2024.111718. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2024.111718

Thwaites S, Abrahams J, Thewlis D, Rickman M. The Absence of Reporting Standards and a Lack of Objective, Performance-Based Outcomes Following Intramedullary Nailing of Tibial Shaft Fractures: Findings from a Scoping Review Into 179 Articles. European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery. 2024 Feb; 50(1): 59-70. doi: 10.1007/s00068-023-02338-1. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00068-023-02338-1

Oliveira PR, Leonhardt MC, Panico CT, Silva JB, Carvalho VC, Kojima KE et al. Infection After Intramedullary Nailing of Femoral and Tibial Diaphyseal Fractures. Injury. 2023 Nov; 54: 110821. doi: 10.1016/j.injury.2023.05.052. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2023.05.052

Karthik MV and Kiran Kumar V. Functional Outcomes of Intramedullary Nailing Versus Plating in Tibial Shaft Fractures: A Prospective Comparative Study. Journal of Advanced Healthcare and Medical Sciences. 2025 Mar; 5: 7-12.

Choudri MJ, Hussain S, Bleibleh S, Remtulla M, Karthikeyan R, Cooper J. Semi-Extended Extra-Synovial (SEES) Tibial Intramedullary Nailing Technique: Up to 10 Year Retrospective Analysis of Outcomes and Anterior Knee Pain Rates. Journal of Clinical Orthopedics and Trauma. 2023 Oct; 45: 102274. doi: 10.1016/j.jcot.2023.102274. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcot.2023.102274

Liu H, Xu W, Xiong Y, Zhang J, Xu Z, Wu J. Retrograde Tibial Intramedullary Nail Versus Minimally Invasive Locking Plate for Extra-Articular Distal Tibial Fractures: A Comparative and Retrospective Study. Journal of Orthopedic Surgery and Research. 2024 Aug; 19(1): 481. doi: 10.1186/s13018-024-04979-3. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13018-024-04979-3

Chaudhry YP, Gutierrez-Naranjo JM, Raad M, Ghanem D, Salazar LM, Goodrum JT et al. Risk Factors for Malalignment After Intramedullary Nail Treatment of Distal Tibia Fractures with Associated Fibula Fractures. European Journal of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology. 2024 Aug; 34(6): 3265-73. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00590-024-04062-x